A South Carolina parole board delivered a unanimous verdict Thursday, refusing for the second consecutive time to release Susan Smith, now 55, from prison.
The six-member board rejected Smith’s bid for freedom without a single dissenting vote, closing what had been a highly anticipated and emotionally charged hearing.
Smith was convicted in July 1995 of murdering her sons, three-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex, by letting her car roll into John D. Long Lake in Union County in October 1994.
The boys were discovered strapped inside the vehicle when investigators located it at the lake’s bottom, a detail that shocked the country and made the case one of the most notorious crimes of the 1990s.
What deepened public outrage was Smith’s initial conduct after the drowning, when she fabricated a story claiming a Black man had abducted both children, a lie she sustained for nine days before finally confessing.
Her sentencing allowed for parole eligibility after 30 years, and under South Carolina rules, inmates who are denied must wait approximately two years before they can seek reconsideration.
Among those who argued most forcefully against her release Thursday was the boys’ father, David Smith, who appeared before the board wearing a photograph of Michael and Alex pinned to his suit lapel while visibly fighting back tears.
“It’s been 32 years since I buried Michael and Alex,” he told the board, calling her potential release “an injustice” and joining a long line of witnesses demanding she remain incarcerated.
Smith, represented by attorney Tommy Thomas, addressed the board herself, acknowledging that she had reached her lowest point the day she let the car enter the water, stating, “They were innocent children. They did not deserve to die, and I dropped to my lowest when I let that car go into that lake.”
She and her legal team also pointed to longstanding mental health difficulties and depression as context for her actions, with Smith claiming she had “lost touch with reality” at the time of the killings.
In a bid to demonstrate personal growth, Smith told board members, “I’m not the same person I was 32 years ago. I have matured,” while also expressing what she described as deep remorse for the “unbearable pain” she caused.
The board was unmoved, mirroring the outcome of Smith’s first parole hearing two years earlier, when her ex-husband and 14 additional witnesses delivered statements that contributed to another unanimous denial.
Thursday’s 6-0 ruling means Smith will remain at the Women’s Correctional Center and will not be eligible for another reconsideration hearing for roughly two more years under state guidelines.