A striking divergence in retail foot traffic has emerged, with Target (NYSE: TGT) pulling in roughly 21 million additional consumer goods shopping trips annually while its two largest rivals shed visits.

Data compiled by Numerator and shared with Chain Store Age shows that consumer goods-related traffic at Walmart fell 3.1% over the 52-week period ending October 25, while Kroger recorded a 1.5% decline across the same timeframe.

Target’s consumer goods traffic, by contrast, grew 1.4% over that same stretch, a modest percentage that translates into an outsized volume gain given the chain’s scale.

The more striking figure sits behind that traffic number: branded consumer goods spending at Target climbed 3.5%, generating $1.4 billion in incremental annual revenue.

That branded momentum signals shoppers are returning to Target with specific purchasing intent rather than simply browsing, a meaningful qualitative shift for a retailer that spent much of 2025 fighting to rebuild consumer trust.

Separate analysis from Placer.ai reinforces the loyalty angle, showing that Q3 visits rose 7.2% year over year and that the share of repeat visitors reached its highest level in three years.

“Those gains appear to rest on Target’s regulars coming back more often,” Placer.ai reported, noting that 48.2% of visitors came at least twice a month in Q3 2026, up 1.6 percentage points from Q3 2024, while 8.8% visited five or more times per month, up 1.2 percentage points.

Store remodels have played a role, with one industry expert telling TheStreet that Target succeeded by refocusing on core categories: “They flipped the script by dropping the fluff and focusing on why people actually walk into their stores every week: groceries and essentials.”

However, the Numerator data carries a significant caveat, as private label spending at Target dropped 7% over the period, representing a $500 million annual loss that complicates the broader recovery narrative.

One analyst offered a counterintuitive explanation, suggesting Target’s own branding success may have undercut the value perception of its store brands: “When people see Kirkland at Costco, they generally think they’re getting a good deal. Now that shoppers are watching their spending, that could be working against Target. Target may have done such a good job making private labels desirable that shoppers no longer see them as a way to save money.”

Retail expert Maurie Backman pointed to an operational issue as well, arguing that “Target lacks some consistency across its private labels, which may explain why sales are down.”

The net picture is a retailer gaining meaningful ground on branded merchandise and loyal repeat customers while simultaneously losing ground in the private label segment it had invested heavily to develop.