The world should reject anti-Armenian propaganda and join Artsakh in promoting mutual understanding and tolerance between Armenians and Azerbaijanis.
Sports competitions are normally perceived to carry the message of peace and unity. Olympics, Jeux de la Francophonie, Maccabiah games, other similar tournaments – the entire civilized humankind has always supported events that connect people, eliminate barriers, and foster mutual understanding.
Those ideas and values are at the core of the Pan-Armenian games, which brings together Armenians around the globe to compete in basketball, soccer, tennis, volleyball and so on. The opening ceremony of the 2019 Pan-Armenian games took place this August in the Republic of Artsakh (also referred to as Nagorno Karabakh Republic) – a small country that has defended on a battlefield its right for freedom, and currently moves towards universal recognition of its rights and liberties.
Artsakh is an integral part of historic Armenia. As such Artsakh is mentioned in the works of Strabo, Pliny the Elder, Claudius Ptolemy, Plutarch, Dio Cassius, and other ancient authors. It was severed from Armenia when the Red Army entered the South Caucasus, and the Bolshevik dictator Stalin decided in 1921 to place Artsakh as Armenian autonomy into newly-created Soviet Azerbaijan, as part of the Soviet Union.
Seventy years later, the autonomy’s legislature legally abolished this illegitimate voluntaristic decision. In fact, the freedom movement in Artsakh became the first truly democratic movement in then-Soviet area, which sparked similar processes across the USSR.
The Republic of Artsakh has been proclaimed in 1991 in accordance with the same Soviet legislation that provided sovereignty to all Soviet republics, and has since been developing as a sovereign democracy with open society, effective governance, a strong military and fledgling market-oriented economy. The republic has its own President, Parliament, Cabinet of ministers, capable defense forces and a vibrant civil society. All rounds of presidential, parliamentary and municipal elections were assessed by international observers as free and transparent.
Unfortunately, leadership of the neighboring Azerbaijan – a country that continues to be ranked among the most corrupt and cruel dictatorships on the globe – still refuses to accept Artsakh’s right for freedom, and continues military and political attacks against our young republic. In 1991, and in 2016, Baku launched full-scale military offensives against Artsakh, both times unsuccessfully attempting to ‘solve the problem’ by conquering the republic, and exterminating its entire population.
Long-term anti-Armenian policy by Azerbaijani leaders has led to aggressive public hatred towards everything Armenian. Azeri President Aliyev’s calling Armenians of the world enemy number one; proclaiming Azerbaijani officer Ramil Safarov, who axed to death sleeping Armenian officer Gurgen Margaryan during NATO-sponsored training program in Hungary, a national hero and an example for younger generations; ordering police to stop the UK’s Arsenal soccer club fans merely for wearing shirts with the name of Henrik Mkhitaryan, who is of Armenian descent; threats to knowingly shoot down any civilian plane flying in or our Artsakh – these are just a few in a long row of the displays of Baku’s continued policy of intolerance and ‘armenophobia’.
And these are just a few among many other reasons why the recent article in Foreign Policy Journal by Mr. Giovanne Vincent Romero titled ‘The 2019 Pan-Armenian Games Have Dimmed Prospects for Peace’—in which he argues that by holding sport competitions in Artsakh, Armenians undermined prospects for reconciliation between Armenians and Azerbaijanis—rather raises questions than provides answers.
It is such policy by Azerbaijan, and not a sporting event in Artsakh, that leaves no hope for a comprehensive peaceful solution of the Artsakh-Azerbaijan conflict anytime soon. Nonetheless, Artsakh will continue its constructive involvement with the international community towards security and stability in the South Caucasus. The republic will also continue to strengthen as a free and democratic home for every Armenian.
The attention of Mr. Romero and others, who assume the responsibility to write about this complicated matter, is duly appreciated. We in Artsakh are interested in having international awareness about the true essence of our cause. At the same time, the article by Mr. Romero unfortunately missed important points regarding the conflict, some of which are mentioned above.
Offering opinion with vividly incomplete expertise in the Azerbaijan-Artsakh conflict can become additional tool for the corrupt regime in Baku for manipulation with facts, justification of numerous domestic political and economic shortcomings, and renewed aggression against neighbors.
Instead, every effort should be directed toward stopping anti-Armenian propaganda in Azerbaijan and joining Artsakh in promoting mutual understanding and tolerance between Armenians and Azerbaijanis. Trust, not hatred, is a necessary prerequisite for any lasting peace.

I read Romero’s article and can just sum it up as “inexperience” or intentional to please the “sponsor”.
Thank you for explaining so coherently that the people of Artsakh voted for their independence according to the Soviet Constitution. They were then invaded by the newly formed Republic of Azerbaijan and they succeedsfuly rebuffed this invasion and occupation.
From my comment to Foreign Policy Journal’s FB question … who is right, Avetisyan or Romero?
The question should not be not which article is right or wrong. Rather, the article, “The 2019 Pan-Armenian Games Have Dimmed Prospects for Peace” is an anti-Armenian effort, with little or no background information provided by the author. The author, Geovanny Vicente Romero bases conclusions on false premises or none at all. Romero assumes his readership is unable to think for themselves — another poor assumption. See my full expository reader comment on the Romero article.
-Yerevan, Armenia
The word “Artsakh” is associated with the names of the ancient Turkic tribes, and means “brave sak”, “sak man”. B.C from the second century onwards, the present-day Karabakh region and some of the southern (Southern Azerbaijan) territories were called Artsakh.
Pan-Armenian Games held in the occupied territories of Azerbaijan is a step to instigate war instead of message aimed at peaceful settlement of conflict!
Foreign Policy, what is the price of publishing such propaganda aricle, filled with pseudo-history in your website? I guess, not so expensive, considering how often your readers face such disgusting lies.
Illegally holding sports events in another country’s territory and calling it a “message of peace” is hypocrisy at its highest level. Armenia tries to legalize occupation of Azerbaijan’s territories by organizing this games in Nagorno-Karabakh region of Azerbaijan.
What peaceful message can these “games” give if it is fully politically motivated?! Indeed, the publication of such articles, based on lies and propaganda, is really harmful to the public image of the of “Foreign Policy Journal” .
Separatist regime in azerbaijani territories is unrecognized and fake. Armenia doesnt support peace, if it did, Armenia would withdraw its troops and follow UN resolutions. Maraga monument built by armenians for 150 anniversary of resettlement of armenians to Karabakh proves that Karabakh belongs to Azerbaijan and armenians are aliens to the region
An average 30 year old who lives in Artsakh speaks Armenian, watches Armenian TV channels, listens to Armenian music, uses Armenian Dram for his daily shopping, reads Armenian newspapers. An average 30 years old who lives in Artsakh has never been to Azerbaijan, does not speak or even understand Azerbaijani language, has never met any Azeri. The idea that you can force this man to one day live as part of Azerbaijan is absurd. It becomes even more absurd once you take into account that Azerbaijan is a corrupt dictatorship that doesn’t respect the rights of its own citizens, let alone a minority hated by the overwhelming majority of its people. The sooner Azerbaijanis understand this the better for the whole region.
Facts:
Constitution of the Soviet Union (1977)
Chapter 11. The Autonomous Region and the Autonomous Area
Article 86. An Autonomous Region is a constituent part of a Union Republic or Territory. The Law on an Autonomous Region, upon submission by the Council of People’s Deputies of the Autonomous Region concerned, shall be adopted by the Supreme Council of the Union Republic.
Article 87. The Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic includes the Adygei, Gorno-Altai, Jewish, Karachai-Circassian, and Khakass Autonomous Regions. The Georgian Soviet Socialist Republic includes the South Ossetian Autonomous Region. The Azerbaijan Soviet Socialist Republic include the Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Region. The Tajik Soviet Socialist Republic includes the Gorno-Badakhshan Autonomous Region.
Article 88. An autonomous Area is a constituent part of a Territory or Region. The Law on an Autonomous Area shall be adopted by the Supreme Council of the Union Republic concerned.
Myth :
The Republic of Artsakh has been proclaimed in 1991 in accordance with the same Soviet legislation that provided sovereignty to all Soviet republics.
Ya, and the word “dəlivəri” is of Dalmatian origin, meaning creative etymology. It’s related to the word “axmax” which is not part of any known language family, however it was introduced into neo-Turkic tribes by crypto-Serbian immigrants from Crimea (not Armeno-Kipchak as many Azerbaijani historians suggest). The word was thought to mean high intellectual capacity. Eventually “axmax” devolved into its modern Azerbaijani meaning, dumbo or stupid.
My response above is to Orkhan.
This article is full of armenian propaganda, based only on shameless lies and disinformation. So-called “artsakh” is just an armenian formation, created by their criminal government on occupied Azerbaijan territories.
When was the Armenians Karabakh? Does the Armenian hash know the history of Karabakh? Armenians did not have their own territory. Karabakh is the historic territory of Azerbaijan. Armenians are poor and ignorant of their history
Fact:
Article 2: The decision on a Union republic’s secession from the USSR is made by a free expression of the will of the Union republic’s people by means of a referendum (popular vote).
Article 3:The people of autonomous republics and autonomous formations retain the right to decide independently the question of remaining within the USSR or within the seceding Union republic, and also to raise the question of their own state-legal status.
From Law on Procedure for Resolving Questions Connected with a Union Republic’s Secession from the USSR. April 3, 1990
The population of Nagorno-Karabakh did exactly as it states above and voted in a referendum to secede from Azerbaijan.
Article which overwhelms with distorted historical “facts” which are merely part of regular Armenian propaganda and nothing more. “Armenia” is a geographical name (a toponym) of nowadays eastern Turkey, “the Hay people”(nowadays armenians) moved to that region from the west, got localized and started naming themselves by the name of the geographical location. Karabakh was never the homelland of those “hay” people. Because of the conquests, they gradually were resettled in south Caucasus (to which nowadays armenians are aliens as the race).
Besides, starting from app. 13 century, the resettled “Hays” were merely small minority group among turkic Azerbaijani muslim population.
Regarding the Soviet occupation, Stalin decided to keep Nagorno-Karabakh within Azerbaijan (not to give), since Nagorno-Karabakh and 7 adjacent regions were already part of the Azerbaijani Democratic Republic before.
The world is fullly fed with your falsification. Stop your terror, stop armenian occupation.
Hatred only propagates more hatred and is detrimental to the future of both Azeris and Armenians. The only person who benefits from escalating this cycle of hatred is Iham Aliev who is robbing us blind. I personally don’t care if Armenians have Sports Tournament in Karabakh.
“Illegally”…LOL…since when did sports become legal or illegal. It appears you have no clue about international tourism in Artsakh, whether sports events or not.
Armenians dont want to serve their sons in occupied azerbaijani territies because they perfectly know that these lands belong to Azerbaijan, and Azerbaijan will free its lands. For establishing peace Armenia first of all to follow resolutions of UN Security Council and withdraw its troops from azerbaijani occupied lands. After it, can be continue negotiations and establish peace in the region
Azerbaijan founded in 1918, Coca Cola founded in 1892 – this pretty much settles everything:)
Myth : Artsakh is an integral part of historic Armenia. As such Artsakh is mentioned in the works of Strabo, Pliny the Elder, Claudius Ptolemy, Plutarch, Dio Cassius, and other ancient authors
Fact: Artsakh toponym is originating Arsacid dynasty who ruled in today Armenia, also called Arshakuni, (247 bc–ad 224), ancient Iranian dynasty that founded and ruled the Parthian empire. The progenitors of the dynasty were members of the Parni tribe living east of the Caspian Sea.
This is illegial games.l think world still do not know Armenia….Kharabakh is an integral part of historic Azerbaijan.
Fuad, games can be illegal as much as freedom can be illegal, or sunshine, or computer games, or cup of coffee. Your oppressive government brainwashed you. Try to understand that people are entitled to play basketball whenever they want to.
WRONG! Totally anti-academic B/S. Look guys, read Strabo or Herodotus or other antic authors and find about Armenia on dozens of pages and NOTHING EVER about “historic Azerbaijan.” So, a questions for Azerbaijani activists: which antic author has ever mention what you refer to as “historic Azerbaijan”?
Kerim, read books. or at least read Wikipedia.
Fidan, now answer: which antic author has EVER mentioned about historic Azerbaijan, the fake narrative you referred to. Strabo? Herodotus? Go ahead, I am waiting for your reply. So?
Ara……….almost fell on the floor laughing.