A federal worker who asked to stop receiving religiously themed messages from Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins was told opting out was “not possible” and that persisting would “create trouble” for her.
That detail figured prominently in a preliminary injunction issued Thursday by U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson, a Biden appointee based in California, barring Rollins from leveraging her official position to send unwanted religious content to Department of Agriculture staff.
The ruling centers on two mass emails Rollins sent to all USDA employees, one on Dec. 23, 2025, which included a video on the birth of Jesus Christ, and a second on April 5, 2026, recounting the resurrection.
Both messages referred to Jesus Christ as “our Savior” and “our risen Lord,” language Thompson found likely violated the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause by presenting one set of religious beliefs as universal across the entire agency.
Thompson identified Rollins’ repeated use of first-person plural pronouns as a core problem, writing that “the Secretary’s use of ‘we,’ ‘us,’ and ‘our,’ along with her failure to recognize other religious holidays or acknowledge that other employees may have different beliefs, expresses a culture and environment within the USDA which ostensibly universally conforms with the Secretary’s beliefs.”
The judge added that “there is no way of reading the challenged messages other than ascribing the Secretary’s particular religious view among all its recipients,” making the constitutional breach difficult to argue around.
Thompson grounded her reasoning in First Amendment doctrine, ruling that “the command of the Establishment Clause, thus, is to prohibit the government from using its authority to try to sway an individual’s decision about whether and how to practice their faith.”
The lawsuit was filed in May by the National Federation of Federal Employees alongside six multi-faith and nonreligious workers, who argued Rollins had created a captive audience with no meaningful ability to opt out and had breached the USDA’s own workplace religious expression policies.
NFFE President Randy Erwin welcomed the outcome, stating that “federal employees are public servants, not an audience for their bosses’ personal religious beliefs,” and vowed the union would continue defending members’ constitutional rights.
The ruling arrives against a backdrop of deliberate efforts by the Trump administration to expand religious expression protections in federal workplaces, including 2025 Office of Personnel Management guidance permitting staff to display religious items and discuss faith on the job.
Trump formalized that direction by establishing the White House Faith Office roughly a month after taking office, placing it under the Domestic Policy Council to coordinate with faith-based organizations and identify gaps in federal religious liberty enforcement.
Rollins herself had previously acknowledged that her public statements on faith had drawn legal scrutiny, declaring on the record, “I’ll never stop talking about Jesus,” a comment the court’s order specifically cited.
A USDA spokesperson pushed back sharply on Thursday’s decision, describing it as “a completely unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet Secretary” and confirming the department is weighing its options, including a possible appeal.