Nearly all defendants under 25 convicted of felonies in Washington, D.C., Superior Court between 2022 and 2024 qualified for reduced sentencing under a single local statute, according to federal prosecutors.

That figure, 96%, sits at the center of a growing confrontation between the White House and District authorities after a judge granted probation to a 19-year-old who fired more than 20 rounds into a residential Northwest Washington neighborhood.

Darius Drew pleaded guilty on Aug. 10 to aggravated assault and carrying a pistol without a license following a May 11 incident captured on surveillance footage.

Video showed Drew riding a Lime bike into an alley before opening fire on a parked car, with the ShotSpotter detection system registering 10 shots from that location alone.

Seconds afterward, Drew discharged his weapon toward a nearby house, and a boy shooting basketball at a recreation center was struck in the leg.

Investigators subsequently recovered two firearms, ammunition, and large quantities of suspected narcotics and marijuana from Drew’s home following his May 22 arrest.

Federal prosecutors pushed for a five-year prison term, but Superior Court Judge Jennifer Di Toro instead suspended a two-year sentence and imposed 18 months of supervised probation under the Youth Rehabilitation Act, a D.C. law that permits eligible offenders who committed crimes before age 25 to receive sentences below applicable mandatory minimums and potentially have their convictions set aside.

Drew, who had spent nearly six months in custody, was released Friday over the government’s continued objection to both his release and the application of the youth sentencing provision.

White House spokeswoman Lauren Bis condemned the outcome in pointed terms, saying, “The case illustrates the insanity of Washington, D.C.’s soft-on-crime policies that allow adults to receive just a slap on the wrist for dangerous crimes like firing twenty rounds of ammunition into the community.”

Bis also credited federal enforcement efforts with progress on the ground, adding, “It is remarkable that even with these types of radical policies in place, President Trump’s Safe and Beautiful Task Force has been able to drive down violent crime in our nation’s capital.”

The administration says the task force has now made more than 19,000 arrests in the District, targeting murderers, sex offenders, and drug traffickers, with 1,914 arrests recorded since Aug. 7 alone.

U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro, sworn in on May 28, 2025, had already put the D.C. Council on notice about the Youth Rehabilitation Act in a letter dated Aug. 6, 2025, months before the Drew sentencing.

That letter cited a separate case in which another 19-year-old received probation after pleading guilty to shooting a person in the chest aboard a Metrobus, despite two charges each carrying five-year mandatory minimums.

Pirro wrote plainly of that outcome: “This sentence was a legal sentence only because he was sentenced under the YRA.”

The act, which the D.C. Council expanded in 2018, excludes murder and the most serious sexual abuse offenses but otherwise extends broad sentencing relief across a wide range of felony classifications.

Pirro argued the legislation required reform to properly weigh rehabilitation against public accountability, particularly given how widely it is applied across the District’s young offender population.

The Drew case has sharpened that debate, giving administration officials a concrete example to deploy as federal and local authorities continue to clash over how Washington handles violent crime.