At the current share price, every $100 Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL) spends repurchasing its own stock generates just $2.67 in annual earnings exposure.

That figure compares unfavorably with the $3.59 an equivalent sum would earn after tax sitting in three-month Treasury bills, which yielded 4.33% as of mid-November.

The gap matters because Apple is running one of the largest buyback programs in corporate history, having returned more than $1 trillion to shareholders since 2012, with $850 billion of that coming through repurchases.

Apple’s stock currently trades at 37.4 times forward earnings, just below the 10-year peak of 37.9x reached in late October, and well above the decade average of 24.5x.

On a November episode of the podcast We Study Billionaires, co-host Shawn O’Malley framed the concern plainly: “Apple is now buying back stock at 40 times earnings, which is something we were sort of allergic to as value investors.”

His co-host Daniel Mahncke offered the competing arithmetic: “Apple’s own cash earns about 4% in treasuries right now. So on pure arithmetic, they would probably be better off piling up cash than buying their stock at this price.”

Even accounting for Apple’s healthy growth trajectory, analysts projecting earnings per share rising from $8.98 in fiscal 2026 to $11.76 in fiscal 2029 implies roughly 9.4% annual growth, which still leaves the buyback yield trailing the Treasury return for approximately 3.3 years.

The only level at which the earnings yield on buybacks matches the after-tax Treasury return is around 27.8 times forward earnings, roughly 10 turns below where Apple is trading today.

Apple’s CFO Kevan Parekh disclosed on the April earnings call that the board had authorized a fresh $100 billion buyback, even as fiscal 2026 repurchases of $85.8 billion came in $3.5 billion below the prior year’s $89.3 billion total.

The company also quietly abandoned its longstanding net-cash-neutral financial target on that same call, a shift that analysts took as a signal of greater flexibility in how capital is allocated going forward.

One complicating factor is that buybacks serve a dual purpose, with Apple needing to offset the roughly 55.7 million net shares issued to employees in fiscal 2026, worth approximately $16.1 billion at the average repurchase price.

Repurchases have nonetheless achieved a meaningful structural result, reducing the diluted share count by 30%, from 21.0 billion in fiscal 2017 to 14.7 billion in fiscal 2026.

Not every major company running buybacks faces the same valuation problem, with Berkshire Hathaway (NYSE: BRK-B) repurchasing $9.6 billion of its own stock in the third quarter while trading at just 24.7 times forward earnings, giving it a 4.05% earnings yield that clears the after-tax Treasury hurdle.

Berkshire’s cash reserves also continued to expand, reaching $377.4 billion as of September 30, suggesting the conglomerate is not sacrificing financial flexibility for the sake of buybacks.

Walmart (NYSE: WMT) presents a starker cautionary example, trading at 42.5 times earnings for a 2.35% yield while spending $7.8 billion on buybacks against only $6.8 billion in free cash flow over nine months, partly funded by $10.8 billion in new long-term debt.

The next major data point for Apple will arrive with the December-quarter earnings report, which will reveal whether repurchase volumes remain near the $24.0 billion recorded in the September quarter or moderate further.