A cautionary precedent is forming in the semiconductor and photonics space, and one prominent analyst believes Tesla investors should pay close attention before celebrating any merger headline.
Lumentum Holdings (NASDAQ: LITE) has shed more than 40% of its value since Marvell Technology’s (NASDAQ: MRVL) acquisition offer became public, with shares falling to around $535 against an Oct. 28 closing price near $914.
The erosion stems from the deal’s all-stock structure: Marvell agreed to swap 4.5 of its own shares for every Lumentum share, fixing the share count but leaving the dollar value hostage to Marvell’s stock performance.
With Marvell trading at $138.47 by Thursday’s close, the implied offer value had collapsed from roughly $1,132 per Lumentum share to approximately $623, a dramatic gap from the original 24% premium.
Analyst Gary Black drew a direct line from that outcome to a potential SpaceX acquisition of Tesla (NASDAQ: TSLA), arguing the same mechanics would punish Tesla shareholders even after an initial price surge.
Black anchored his analysis at $374 per Tesla share, where a comparable 24% premium would nominally value a SpaceX bid at around $464 per share on paper.
The problem, in his view, is that funding such a purchase with SpaceX stock would dilute existing SpaceX shareholders by roughly 50%, triggering a wave of selling that would drag the offer’s real-world value sharply lower.
Black posted on X: “The same dynamic is likely when $SPCX offers a +24% premium for $TSLA using SPCX stock as currency: TSLA investors will get a short-term pop on the deal headline and then experience quick downward pressure on $TSLA stock as investors sell $SPCX to try to lock in profits.”
Running that scenario to its conclusion, Black estimated Tesla could find itself trading near $280 within a month, roughly 25% below where it started before any deal was announced.
Both Tesla and SpaceX have already established independent board committees to evaluate a potential merger, lending the scenario more than hypothetical weight.
Black first raised the Lumentum comparison on Nov. 2 when LITE was still trading around $750, and within two days the stock had dropped 27% while Marvell had fallen 31% from its own Oct. 28 levels.
Meanwhile, Lumentum CEO Michael Hurlston has been working to shore up confidence, appearing on CNBC’s Mad Money to address shareholder frustration directly.
“We’ve got work to do with our shareholders,” Hurlston told host Jim Cramer, pointing to fiber-optic demand from AI data centers as the strategic rationale for combining Lumentum’s optical components with Marvell’s networking chips.
Lumentum reported quarterly revenue that more than doubled from the prior year, prompting Hurlston to say, “Their numbers are phenomenal. Our numbers are phenomenal, and we feel the combination is even more powerful.”
Hurlston identified Marvell’s Dec. 1 earnings report, Lumentum’s upcoming results, and a pending merger filing as the near-term catalysts that could restore investor confidence, adding, “I think we’re going to get that multiple back once we can show our numbers and show how strong the two businesses are doing.”
Retail traders on Stocktwits appear unconvinced, with sentiment registered as bearish on both Marvell and Lumentum amid low message volume for each stock.
Some users called outright for Lumentum to walk away from the deal, with at least one preferring the company pay a breakup fee and pursue a buyer willing to offer closer to $1,200 per share.
Sentiment on Tesla and SpaceX was classified as neutral with normal-to-low message volume, suggesting the market has not yet priced in the full merger risk Black is flagging.
Despite the post-announcement slide, year-to-date performance tells a more complicated story: Marvell remains up roughly 63% and Lumentum up around 45%, while Tesla has lost nearly 17% and SpaceX sits just 2.5% above its June IPO price.