A potential union of Elon Musk’s two largest companies carries consequences far beyond Wall Street’s active managers, reaching into the retirement accounts of millions of ordinary Americans.
Reid Noch, an analyst at TD Securities, estimates that passive index funds tracking the S&P 500 would be compelled to purchase roughly $100 billion of stock if a merged Tesla-SpaceX entity retained Tesla’s current seat in the index.
That figure reflects the scale of passive capital at stake: Bloomberg has reported that approximately $16 trillion in investment money tracks the S&P 500, meaning even a fractional reweighting sends enormous sums in motion.
For a concrete illustration, Tesla (NASDAQ: TSLA) represented 1.69% of the SPDR S&P 500 ETF as of November 13, meaning a hypothetical retiree with $500,000 in that fund holds roughly $8,425 in the automaker today.
If a combined Musk company inherited that index position, TD’s estimate implies the same retiree’s exposure would grow to around $11,550, with a portion of that now representing a rocket and satellite business she never selected.
As Interactive Brokers chief strategist Steve Sosnick told Bloomberg, “You own all those stocks whether you knowingly intended to or not.”
The merger talks themselves have been confirmed by Bloomberg, which reported on November 12 that discussions between the two companies are advancing, and followed on November 14 with reporting that a formal announcement could come as early as December.
SpaceX (NASDAQ: SPCX) listed on public markets in June and is therefore ineligible for S&P 500 inclusion until it has traded for a full year, making a merger with Tesla potentially the fastest path into the index for Musk’s space venture.
Musk addressed the prospect directly on SpaceX’s third-quarter earnings call, describing a combination as a “good idea” and saying “there’s a lot of merit to combining the companies,” while noting he is recused from board-level discussions as a “conflicted party.”
Both companies have formed special committees of independent directors to evaluate the deal, and Barclays has identified an all-stock structure as the most probable outcome, with SpaceX acquiring Tesla and Tesla shareholders receiving SpaceX shares in exchange.
A successful deal would require approval from holders of at least 50% of all outstanding Tesla shares, with Tesla’s annual shareholder meeting scheduled for December 3 providing an early public forum for the discussion.
At Friday’s prices, the two companies carried a combined market value of nearly $3.5 trillion, which would place the merged entity fifth among all S&P 500 constituents by market capitalization.
Regulatory scrutiny is already forming: Texas Attorney General-elect Nathan Johnson has pledged “tremendous scrutiny” of any transaction and is set to take office in January.
Nobody has more concentrated exposure to the outcome than Cathie Wood’s ARK Investment Management, which disclosed in a November 13 filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission that it held $2.214 billion across the two stocks as of September 30, amounting to 12.7% of its reported $17.37 billion portfolio.
Tesla represented ARK’s single largest position at $1.196 billion, or 6.9% of assets, while SpaceX ranked second at $1.018 billion, or 5.9%, and ARK aggressively added to both during the third quarter, raising its Tesla stake by 22% and SpaceX holdings by 51%.
ARK’s internal research underpins the conviction: the firm argues that cash generated by Tesla’s robotaxi network could finance SpaceX’s spending on rockets and AI infrastructure, and its base-case price target places Tesla at $4,400 per share by 2031, with robotaxi revenue accounting for 81% of that projected value.
GuruFocus reported that ARK added approximately $96 million of additional SpaceX shares across three of its ETFs during the first week of November alone, suggesting Wood has been accelerating her position as merger speculation intensified.
If the S&P 500 index committee declines to grant the combined company Tesla’s existing seat and awards it instead to another firm, index funds would be sellers rather than buyers of the shares they receive in the transaction, reversing the $100 billion dynamic entirely.